
Legislation & Policy
What’s Changing for Virginia’s ACA Marketplace in 2026

Brandon Beavers
9.11.25
Overview
If you have or plan to get health insurance through Virginia’s Insurance Marketplace, expect some noticeable shifts in what you pay and what help is available in 2026.
If you have or plan to get health insurance through Virginia’s Insurance Marketplace, expect some noticeable shifts in what you pay and what help is available in 2026. Many of the enhanced federal subsidies are set to expire, insurers are requesting large premium increases, and more people may lose eligibility or face higher costs. Here’s the rundown.
Background: Key Federal Subsidies Expiring
Since 2021, the enhanced premium tax credits (PTCs) under the American Rescue Plan (and partially extended via later legislation) have made Marketplace plans cheaper for many. These enhancements cap what people pay for premiums relative to their income and extend eligibility.
These enhanced subsidies are scheduled to expire December 31, 2025, unless Congress acts to renew them. That means for plans beginning January 1, 2026, you may see substantially less assistance.
What’s Expected in Virginia in 2026
Here are the main changes projected in Virginia, with how they could affect you:
🔺 Premium Increases
Insurers in the Virginia individual market are proposing average premium increases of 20% or more for 2026, compared to 2025. Some are much higher.
For the small group market (businesses under 50 workers), the proposed average increase is somewhat smaller, ~11.2%.
One particular insurer, Optimum Choice, is proposing a ~40.2% increase. Others vary, with some lower (e.g. ~11–17%) depending on the plan and insurer.
⚙️ Subsidy Changes & Reduced Financial Help
With expiration of the enhanced tax credits, many Virginians will see smaller subsidies (premium tax credits) for 2026, meaning higher net monthly premiums.
Fewer people will qualify or get as much help, especially those whose incomes are above certain thresholds. In particular, people above 400% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) will again lose eligibility for subsidies once those enhanced credits expire.
👤 Market Participation & Insurer Withdrawals
Two insurers, Aetna and Innovation Health, are leaving Virginia’s individual Marketplace at the end of 2025. If you have coverage with them now, you’ll need to pick a new insurer during Open Enrollment.
With fewer carriers, plan options may shrink in some areas, and this could reduce competition, possibly increasing costs or reducing choices.
🚨 Potential Impacts on Enrollees
Without enhanced subsidies, premiums for some could jump significantly. For example, those with incomes between 100% and 200% of the FPL may see monthly insurance contributions rise dramatically without additional tax credit help.
Up to 100,000 Virginians might lose coverage or be priced out of the Marketplace if the subsidy enhancements are not preserved.
📆 Open Enrollment & Support
Virginia’s open enrollment period for 2026 plans: November 1, 2025 through January 30, 2026.
The state will provide help via agents, navigators, or certified application counselors. These resources will be valuable because of the additional complexity.
What You Can Do / Tips for Virginia Enrollees
To reduce surprises and potential increases in what you pay, consider the following:
Estimate your income carefully for 2026
Your eligibility for subsidies is based on your projected income. If you underestimate, you may have to repay. If you overestimate, you might miss assistance.Compare plan options early
Because carriers are leaving and premiums are changing, shopping early gives you more time to see what’s offered in your area and consider trade-offs (premiums vs out-of-pocket costs).Check your eligibility
If you’re near subsidy cutoff levels or recently immigrated, check whether your eligibility has changed or will change under new rules. Recently arrived lawfully present immigrants with incomes under the poverty level may lose eligibility beginning 2026.Be aware of envelope costs
Even if monthly premiums seem reasonable, higher deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, and co-pays can make your plan more expensive overall.Keep up with documentation / tax filings
Because subsidies are based on income and tax filings, make sure your tax documents are in order and that you reconcile any advance payments you got via the Marketplace with what you report to the IRS.Monitor Congressional or State Actions
Since federal policy could change (if enhanced subsidies are extended), keep an eye out for updates. Also, state policy could respond (Virginia may consider ways to make up for losses if federal help disappears).
Bottom Line: What You’ll Likely Pay More For
If nothing changes:
Monthly premiums: Much higher for many, especially those currently benefiting from enhanced credits.
Net cost after subsidies: Likely to increase substantially for people who had low or zero premiums now.
Coverage gaps or drop-offs: Some people may decide to go without coverage if they see the new cost is unaffordable.
That said, some subsidy help will still be available in 2026 – it just may not go as far. Virginia also has tools (like its reinsurance program) that help moderate increases somewhat.
Let's Get to Work
