
Benefits Strategy
Would You Buy a New TV and Never Open the Box?

Brandon Beavers
11.19.26
Overview
The most expensive benefits mistake I see is paying for the richest plan and never using it. For a lot of employees, an HSA is the smarter play.
Every open enrollment somebody tells me, "I want the best plan." My first question back is always the same. Best for what? Best for your wallet? Best for someone who sees their primary care doctor twice a year? Best for someone with a surgery on the calendar? Those are three different answers.
Here's the mistake I see over and over again. Employees pick the lowest deductible, richest copay plan on the menu, pay the highest premium, and then never use it.
So I ask them this. Would you go buy a brand new Samsung TV and never open the box? Why'd you buy it?
You're giving premium dollars away
If you're healthy and rarely use your plan, those extra premium dollars are gone the day they come out of your check. You're paying for a Cadillac and never driving it.
The alternative is a high deductible health plan paired with a Health Savings Account. You pay a lower premium and put the difference into an HSA, pre-tax. I think of it as a retirement plan for medical expenses, because sooner or later we all have them.
Why the HSA is so powerful
The HSA is the only account I know of with a triple tax benefit at the federal level:
Money goes in pre-tax
It grows tax free
It comes out tax free for qualified medical expenses
And unlike an FSA, it's your money. It doesn't disappear at the end of the year and it goes with you when you change jobs.
Three ways I see people use it
1. Let it grow. Most HSA providers let you invest anything above a minimum cash balance, just like a 401(k). Some of my clients max it out every year, pay medical bills out of pocket and let the account grow for the medical costs they'll have later in life.
2. Pay as you go. Others contribute just enough to cover bills as they come in. That still gets you the tax break, but you never build anything up, so you're leaving a lot on the table.
3. Pay now, reimburse later. This is what I do. I pay the bill with my credit card, collect the points, snap a picture of the receipt and submit it for reimbursement from my HSA. A few days later I pay the card off with pre-tax dollars. Some folks save their receipts all year and reimburse themselves in one shot around the holidays. Just keep good records.
When the richer plan does make sense
An HSA isn't right for everyone. If you have a chronic condition, a baby on the way or a procedure you know is coming, the lower deductible plan may well be the better deal. That's exactly why we walk through real examples with employees instead of pushing one plan.
I don't go into an enrollment meeting to sell a health plan. I go in to educate. When people understand what they're buying, they make better decisions on their own.
If you want help modeling the options for your team, give me a ring. And if you want to hear more of how I think about this, I talked about it on The Inspired Stories Podcast.
This post is general information, not tax or investment advice. HSA eligibility, contribution limits and state tax treatment vary, so talk with your tax advisor about your situation.
Let's Get to Work
